Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva's remark on Thursday that the emergency decree may be lifted before the new year in Bangkok, Pathum Thani, Nonthaburi and Samut Prakan provinces is most encouraging, and is hopefully a sign that the country is indeed returning to ''normal''. In this case, normal means that people would be able to exercise their constitutionally guaranteed freedoms without the threat of incarceration. Hopefully it also means that fully armed soldiers will soon no longer be patrolling BTS and MRT stations. This is a sight that seems more suited to Rangoon than Bangkok, regardless of a statement from Centre for the Resolution of the Emergency Situation (CRES) spokesman Col Sansern Kaewkamnerd that a CRES survey shows that passengers ''feel safe'' in the presence of the armed soldiers.
The state of emergency decree was instigated by former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra in 2005 as a means to deal with the unrest in the South. Much has been made of the irony of it now being used against Thaksin's supporters.
As explained by Chulalongkorn law professor Vitit Muntarbhorn in an opinion piece in the Bangkok Post last month, the decree has been the subject of a great deal of debate because of its inherent anomalies. The law allows the authorities to limit the exercise of various rights such as the freedoms of expression, communication and assembly. A person can be arrested with a court warrant and detained for seven days without access to the courts; this is renewable, leading to possible preventive detention for 30 days without trial before the courts.
Section 12 of the decree enables the authorities to detain people in unofficial locations (beyond prisons and official detention centres), leading to opacity in the administration of justice. The law prevents aggrieved persons from gaining access to the administrative courts to seek redress. Moreover, officials carrying out their duties are exempted from responsibility, thus giving rise to the shield of impunity.
Prof Vitit said that the assumption is that draconian measures such as the emergency decree will only be resorted to temporarily, but the continued renewal (required every three months) of the emergency decree has given rise to what he calls the ''permanency of the temporary'' in the South, which strikes at the heart of the constitution. The decree has been in effect almost seven months now in Bangkok and vicinity and if it is not lifted soon the same situation will apply here.
It must be admitted that for the most part the emergency decree has not been enforced nearly as stringently in Bangkok and adjacent provinces as its provisions allow. For example, peaceful demonstrations have been allowed by both the red and yellow shirt factions.
Yet there is little doubt that the decree has in some cases been applied indiscriminately and innocent people have suffered. Mr Abhisit practically admitted as much when he invited two men who had been detained on a charge of violating the emergency decree _ Sommai Inthanakha, 32, and Boonyarit Sodakham, 24 _ to meet him at the parliament building last week. That's not exactly the sort of offer the leader of a nation makes to a couple of terrorists.
The prime minister asked them about their health and how they had been treated while in detention. The two men were entitled to bail but they had no money to put down as a guarantee. With help from the Justice Ministry they were released on Nov 9. Mr Abhisit reportedly has asked the Justice Ministry to expedite the release of 48 others detained under the decree who cannot post bail.
Of course, some of those detained under the emergency decree may very well be dangerous to society and belong behind bars. In such circumstances hopefully criminal cases can be made, but on balance the suspension of constitutional protections for the whole population has a much more harmful and chilling effect on society than letting a few bad guys go free.
Prime Minister Abhisit said that all security agencies would have to reassess the situation before a final decision was made to lift the decree. Clearly the red shirt demonstrations planned for this weekend and next will figure prominently in the reassessment. It is vital that they remain peaceful, not only to end the emergency decree in Bangkok, but also to allow the process of reconciliation to gain strength in the new year.
No comments:
Post a Comment