Monday, November 15, 2010

They don't even go red in the face

The International Anti-Corruption Conference took place in Bangkok this past week, something that prompted a few wry smiles when it was first announced.
They are certainly in the right place if they want to pick up first-hand knowledge of the art of wheeling and dealing.
It would be nice to get through at least one breakfast without reading in the Bangkok Post some sort of story concerning the alleged misappropriation of funds by persons unknown, or often known but seldom named.
Open the newspaper on just about any day and there will be items about a dodgy contract, or even dodgier dealings and sharp practices, on just about any subject you wish to name - airport security devices, school milk, forests, kindergarten toys, jelly babies or even garbage disposal. It's almost as if it's a national sport.
Of course bribery has been in existence all over the world for a very long time. English statesman Francis Bacon, who was in charge of financial affairs at the turn of the 16th century, was fined 40,000 after confessing to accepting bribes.
Writer Edmund Clerihew Bently eloquently described Bacon's reaction in parliament when facing interrogation about his financial misdemeanors:
When their lordships asked Bacon
How many bribes he had taken
He at least had the grace
To go red in the face.
Unfortunately in Thailand we don't even see anybody go red in the face... unless they've been hitting the amber liquid.

Tasty pastry

Some attempts at bribery display considerable creativity. Readers may recall an incident in Bangkok just over two years ago in what local newspapers dubbed "Pastrygate". It featured a pastry lunchbox apparently intended for a judge presiding over an important case. Nothing wrong in that, of course, but after the box was examined by a court official, it turned out it was stuffed with 2 million baht in banknotes, covered by a few stale pastries.
It was eventually determined that the delivery man was a lawyer's clerk whose boss was representing an influential person under indictment.
The delivery man explained there was nothing underhand about it, but simply a "mistake". He claimed he was carrying two packages and simply handed over the wrong one. A perfectly reasonable explanation. But what was he doing with a pastry box stuffed with 2 million baht in the first place? A shopping expedition perhaps?
However, it seemed rather a lot of cash to carry around for a trip to the local supermarket or mall. In the end the two million baht was handed back to the lawyer's clerk after his unfortunate absent-mindedness. Amazingly, three people involved actually ended up doing six months, although one of them had to be extracted from a hospital after he had suddenly been stricken with a mystery illness possibly called "guilt".

The thought was there

Just about every new government announces a crackdown on corruption, news which is usually greeted by the public with appropriate yawns and stifled guffaws. You don't have to be Sherlock Holmes to conclude that over the years such crackdowns invariably end up cracking up.
Any investigations usually get no further than an interrogation of the ubiquitous go-between, who invariably suffers immediate memory loss as does everyone else involved. The case then ends up in the pending file at the Ministry of Sweeping Things Under The Carpet. Rarely does anyone actually do "porridge", although occasionally someone stupid enough to get caught ends up in an inactive post.
On the street, meanwhile, life goes on. There is hardly a motorist who hasn't been asked to contribute to the "widows and orphans fund" by one of those friendly gentlemen in brown who guard our highways so diligently. Certainly most motorists in Bangkok who are stopped for actual or imaginary offences tend to settle for discreetly paying on the spot with a few red notes, primarily to avoid the tedious business of handing over a licence and going through the red tape at the police station.

Returning a favour

The unique aspect of a bribe is that it is the rare time that the givers say "thanks" while the receivers say "don't mention it".
Of course in Thailand there have been bold attempts over the years to sort things out once and for all. One of the more intriguing initiatives took place a decade ago when it was announced that a special fund would be set up to pay back people who had bribed government officials to get things done - or, in some cases, not get things done. It was not immediately clear how this was going to be enforced in practice, but at least it sounded sort of democratic.
It prompted images of a stampede of ex-bribers rolling up to reclaim their unofficial donations. The problem was that it involved so many people it was going to lead to big queues, meaning a lot of hanging around. Unfortunately, one of the main reasons small-scale, under-the-table payments are made in the first place is to avoid long queues and avoid lengthy waits. Bribers don't queue.
As it looked like things could end up with the magnificent situation of bribers offering more bribes to speed things up in order to get back their original bribes, the scheme was hastily dropped.

No comments:

Post a Comment